Corporate gifting guide

Do Employees Prefer Choosing Their Own Gift? What the Survey Data Says

Every published survey we could trace says most employees would rather choose their gift. Here are the numbers, who collected them, and how far they can be trusted.

The North Face jacket, one of the options an employee might pick in a choice-based gift program

Yes: in every published survey we could trace to its original source, a majority of employees say they would rather choose their own gift than receive one picked for them. The share ranges from 52% to 75% depending on the year, the sample and how the question was worded. All of these surveys were run by companies that sell gifts, so the numbers below come with the name of whoever collected them, the sample size and the year.

This page is the data. For how a choice-based program actually runs, see the corporate gifting pop-up shops guide.

What Does the Survey Data Say About Employee Gift Choice?

Across five surveys from two vendors between 2018 and 2026, between 52% and 75% of respondents preferred choosing their own gift, and the alternative (the same gift for everyone, or the employer choosing) never drew more than 32%. The preference has held for eight years, and Snappy's own series, with a different sample each year, has edged upward from 68% in 2018 to 69% in 2024 and 75% in 2025.

Published survey findings on employee gift choice and unwanted gifts, verified November 2026
FindingWho ran itYearSample
58% of employees prefer to choose from several options; 23% prefer the same gift for everyone; 19% have no preferenceCustom Ink2026502 U.S. employees
Of the gifts employees received most recently, 40% are in regular use, 31% sit unused, 15% were re-gifted or donated, 8% were thrown awayCustom Ink2026Employees who received an employer gift
98% say a gift they love makes them feel more positive about their employerCustom Ink2026502 U.S. employees
75% of employees say they'd love to choose their own giftSnappy20251,500 employed U.S. adults
52% would prefer to choose between several gift options; 31% would prefer the same gift as everyone elseCustom Ink (fielded via Qualtrics)20251,051 U.S. employees, ±3% margin of error
82% would value a gift more if it were personalizedCustom Ink (fielded via Qualtrics)20251,051 U.S. employees
69% of employees would love to choose their gift; 44% feel unappreciated after a badly chosen giftSnappy (sample by Propeller Insights)20241,500 U.S. adults
Nearly 70% have received a gift they didn't want and didn't use; 63% would rather get no gift than a poorly chosen oneSnappy (sample by Propeller Insights)20231,527 U.S. adults
68% would rather choose their own gift than have their employer choose; 32% would rather the employer chooseSnappy20181,019 respondents

The 2026 Custom Ink result is the most specific: it asked about choosing from a curated list of options, not open-ended choice, and still found a majority. It also measured what happens after the gift arrives, and fewer than half of recent employer gifts were in regular use.

Why Do Employees End Up With Gifts They Don't Want?

Unwanted gifts happen because one item has to fit a whole group, and a group never agrees on size, taste or need. The surveys measure the result (unused, re-gifted or binned gifts); the causes are familiar to anyone who has run a program:

  • Sizes. Apparel ordered in a size range always misses someone, and few people ask for an exchange from their employer.
  • Personal preferences. Color, style and brand loyalty split any team; a jacket one person loves is one another would never wear.
  • Diet and lifestyle. Food and drink gifts run into allergies, dietary choices and people who don't drink alcohol.
  • Duplicates. The tumbler or speaker an employee already owns adds clutter, not value.
  • Generic picks. In Custom Ink's 2026 survey, 22% of employees describing their worst gift ever named cheap, generic or branded items.

None of these causes is about budget. A more expensive single item still has to match one person's size, diet and shelf.

What Does "Choice" Actually Mean in a Gift Program?

"Choice" covers three different formats: an open gift card, a curated selection the recipient picks from, and a single pre-picked item with only a size or color option. The surveys rarely separate them, which matters when you read the numbers.

Three formats that get called "choice"
FormatWhat the recipient decidesWhat the company decides
Gift cardAlmost everything: what, where and whenThe amount and the retailer
Curated choiceWhich item from a set list, plus size and colorThe products, the branding and the per-person budget
Pre-picked giftUsually only size or color, if anythingThe single item everyone receives

The Custom Ink questions describe curated choice (several options, or a curated list). Snappy's wording, "choose their own gift", fits both a gift card and a curated selection. We compare the trade-offs of the first two in gift cards vs. gift choice.

Does Letting Employees Choose Change How Appreciated They Feel?

The data shows that fit drives appreciation, and choice is the most direct way to get fit, but no survey we found measures appreciation for chosen gifts against assigned gifts head to head. What the numbers do show is how much a miss costs:

  • Snappy 2025: 42% say a bad gift makes them feel less appreciated than receiving nothing.
  • Snappy 2024: 44% feel unappreciated after a badly selected gift.
  • Snappy 2023: 63% would rather receive no gift than a poorly chosen one.
  • Custom Ink 2026: 98% say a gift they love makes them feel more positive about their employer.

Read together, these say a gift works when the person likes it and can backfire when they don't. Letting each employee pick moves that judgment to the one person who knows the answer. For ideas on what to put in the selection, see corporate gifts for employees and the best corporate gift ideas for 2026.

How Do You Put Employee Gift Choice Into Practice?

The usual way is a branded gift shop: you and a gifting expert agree on a short list of products and a per-person budget, then each employee opens a link, picks one item and enters an address. At Idea Tree Engagement, once we have your brief and your logo, your shop is live within 24 hours.

Online, on-site and hybrid formats, and what happens behind the shop, are covered step by step in the corporate gifting pop-up shops guide.

What Are the Limitations of This Data?

The main limitation is that every survey here was commissioned by a company that sells gifts: Snappy runs a gift-selection platform and Custom Ink sells custom-decorated products. Idea Tree Engagement, which publishes this page, is in the same business. Treat the numbers as a consistent signal, not as independent research. Other caveats:

  • Question wording differs. "Would love to choose" and "prefer several options over the same gift" are not the same question, so the percentages shouldn't be averaged or compared directly.
  • Samples differ. Some surveys polled employed adults only; Snappy's 2023 and 2024 samples were U.S. adults in general.
  • Self-reported. People report what they prefer and what they use; nobody tracked the gifts. Custom Ink notes its retention findings are correlations, not measured turnover.
  • U.S. only, and not peer reviewed. Margins of error are published only for Custom Ink's 2025 survey (±3%).
  • The 2018 figure is old, and we could trace it only through press coverage of Snappy's survey, not a Snappy page.

We dropped figures we couldn't trace to the organization that collected them. If a newer survey appears, we'll add it with the same details.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do employees prefer choosing their own gift?

Most do, according to every survey we could trace. Custom Ink's 2026 survey of 502 U.S. employees found 58% prefer choosing from several options and 23% prefer the same gift for everyone. Snappy's 2025 survey of 1,500 employed U.S. adults found 75% would love to choose their own gift. Both companies sell gifts.

What percentage of employees receive gifts they don't want?

In Snappy's 2023 survey of 1,527 U.S. adults, nearly 70% said they had received a gift they didn't want and didn't use. Custom Ink's 2026 survey found only 40% of employees' most recent employer gifts were in regular use, with 31% unused, 15% re-gifted or donated and 8% thrown away.

Is a gift card the same as letting employees choose?

Not quite. A gift card hands over the whole decision, while a curated selection lets each person pick from items the company has approved and branded. Most survey questions don't separate the two, though Custom Ink's specifically asked about choosing from several options.

Who runs employee gift preference surveys?

The published ones mostly come from gifting companies. The figures on this page come from Snappy, a gift-selection platform, and Custom Ink, a custom products company, sometimes fielded through research firms such as Propeller Insights or Qualtrics. We found no independent academic survey on the same question.

How can a company let employees choose their own gift?

The common approach is a branded gift shop: the company and a gifting expert agree on the products and a per-person budget, then each employee picks one item and enters a shipping address. Our pop-up shops guide covers the formats and steps.

Sources

  1. What 1,011 Buyers and Employees Told Us About Employee Gifting in 2026 — Custom Ink
  2. Employers Miss the Mark on Holiday Gifts: 2025 Employee Holiday Gift Survey — Custom Ink
  3. Snappy Data Reveals the ROI of Thoughtful Holiday Gifting in 2025 — Snappy
  4. What Employees Really Want This Holiday Season: 2025 Insights — Snappy
  5. Holiday Gifting Report Highlights Importance of Holiday Gifting in Boosting Employee Satisfaction and Retention (2024) — Snappy
  6. New Study Reveals 75% of Employees Hope to Receive a Gift from Their Company This Holiday (2023) — Snappy
  7. Good Gifting: What Are You Gifting Your Employees This Holiday Season? (reporting Snappy's 2018 survey) — People Matters
  8. Uh-Oh. What If Your Employees Don't Like Your Holiday Gift? (Snappy's 2018 survey) — Entrepreneur

Trusted by law firms including Fish & Richardson, Weil, Gotshal & Manges and Bradley.

Your cart
0 units

Your cart is empty.

Browse the boutique →